When should a school consider one to one mentoring for a struggling student?
A school should consider one-to-one mentoring for a struggling student when group support has not produced meaningful change, when a young person’s needs are too complex or sensitive for a shared setting, or when they have disengaged so significantly that individual, consistent adult attention is the only realistic route back to stability. The decision is rarely about a single incident: it is about a pattern of difficulty that standard classroom or group interventions have not resolved.
The following questions walk through the key considerations: the warning signs, the differences between individual and group support, who benefits most, and how to make a referral that leads to real outcomes.
What are the signs a student needs one-to-one mentoring?
A student may need one-to-one mentoring when they show persistent patterns of disengagement, emotional withdrawal, or behavioural difficulty that have not responded to whole-class or group-based support. The key indicator is not a single bad week: it is a sustained pattern that suggests the young person needs something more personalised and consistent.
Signs worth taking seriously include:
- Frequent unexplained absences or school avoidance that is escalating rather than stabilising
- Visible anxiety, low mood, or emotional dysregulation that disrupts learning or relationships
- Social withdrawal or difficulty forming safe relationships with peers and trusted adults
- Involvement in or risk of involvement with the criminal justice system
- Significant life events such as bereavement, family breakdown, or experiences of trauma
- A student who actively disengages from group settings but shows flickers of engagement in individual conversations
When a young person consistently falls through the gaps in whole-school provision, one-to-one mentoring creates the dedicated space they need to be heard and supported without the pressure of peers or group dynamics.
How does one-to-one mentoring differ from group support programmes?
One-to-one mentoring differs from group support in that the entire session, relationship, and focus are built around a single young person. There is no shared agenda, no group dynamics to navigate, and no risk of a student masking their difficulties behind more dominant peers. The relationship between mentor and mentee is the primary tool for change.
Group programmes are highly effective for building social skills, peer connection, and shared experience. They work well when a young person can engage with others without becoming overwhelmed, and when the goal is partly about community and belonging. Many students benefit from both formats at different points in their journey.
Individual mentoring, however, is better suited to students who find group settings threatening or overstimulating, who carry experiences too personal to explore alongside peers, or who need a mentor to respond flexibly to what they bring each week. The consistency of seeing the same trusted adult, session after session, is itself a powerful intervention for young people whose relationships with adults have been unreliable or harmful.
Which students benefit most from individual mentoring?
Students who benefit most from one-to-one mentoring are those whose challenges are deeply personal, whose trust in adults has been damaged, or whose needs are not well served by standardised group provision. Individual mentoring works across a wide range of presenting difficulties, but it tends to have the greatest impact where the underlying issue is relational or identity-based.
Young people who respond particularly well to individual mentoring include those experiencing isolation, grief, anxiety, school avoidance, or the pressures associated with criminal justice involvement. Students from communities that face additional systemic barriers, including those from Black, Asian, and Minority Ethnic backgrounds, those eligible for Free School Meals, or those with additional needs, often benefit significantly from a mentoring relationship that is culturally aware and free from institutional pressure.
It is also worth noting that girls and young women are frequently underserved by traditional support structures. Programmes that actively prioritise female participation and create safe, gender-sensitive spaces can make a substantial difference for students who might otherwise remain invisible to intervention systems.
When is one-to-one mentoring not enough on its own?
One-to-one mentoring is not enough on its own when a young person’s needs exceed the scope of a mentoring relationship, for example, when they require clinical mental health treatment, crisis intervention, or statutory safeguarding support. Mentoring is a powerful early and ongoing intervention, but it sits within a broader ecosystem of care.
Schools should treat individual mentoring as one layer of a coordinated response rather than a standalone solution. A student experiencing acute mental health difficulties will need a clinical referral alongside any mentoring support. A young person at risk of harm requires safeguarding processes to run in parallel. Mentoring works best when it is connected to what else is happening in a student’s life: when the mentor can communicate with the school’s pastoral team and when the student’s wider needs are being addressed simultaneously.
The absence of family engagement can also limit outcomes. Where possible, involving parents or carers in understanding what the mentoring programme offers, even if they are not directly part of sessions, creates a more consistent environment for the young person outside school hours.
How should a school refer a student to a mentoring programme?
A school should refer a student to a one-to-one mentoring programme by first establishing a clear picture of the student’s needs, identifying the most appropriate provision, and then making contact through the programme’s referral process. A strong referral includes specific, honest information about the young person’s circumstances: not just a list of presenting behaviours, but context about what has already been tried and why it has not worked.
A straightforward referral process looks like this:
- Identify the need clearly. Document the specific challenges the student is facing and the support already provided. Be honest about what has and has not worked.
- Gain consent. Speak with the student and, where appropriate, their parents or carers. Young people who understand and agree to mentoring engage far more meaningfully than those who feel it has been imposed on them.
- Choose the right provider. Look for a programme that matches the student’s age, background, and presenting needs. Check that the provider has experience working with similar young people and can offer flexibility in timing, location, and format.
- Make contact and share relevant information. Provide the programme with enough context to match the student with the right mentor and structure the support appropriately.
- Stay connected. Maintain communication with the mentoring provider throughout the programme so that school-based and external support can reinforce each other.
What outcomes can schools expect from one-to-one mentoring?
Schools can expect one-to-one mentoring to produce gradual, sustained improvements in a student’s wellbeing, self-confidence, and willingness to engage, both with learning and with the adults around them. Outcomes are rarely dramatic or immediate, but over a structured programme of six to twelve weeks, meaningful shifts become visible.
Typical outcomes include improved school attendance, reduced incidents of emotional dysregulation, stronger relationships with trusted adults, and a greater sense of personal identity and purpose. For students who have experienced significant disengagement, simply re-establishing a consistent, positive relationship with an adult can be the foundation everything else is built on.
Longer-term, young people who receive effective individual mentoring often demonstrate increased resilience, clearer thinking about their futures, and a greater ability to navigate difficult situations without crisis. Where programmes include accredited elements, such as AQA qualifications, students also gain something tangible to show for their progress, which can support reintegration into mainstream education or further learning pathways. You can explore the impact of this work to understand what sustained, evidence-informed provision looks like in practice.
How Guardian Ballers supports students through one-to-one mentoring
Guardian Ballers is an Alternative Provision provider based near Coventry City Centre that delivers structured one-to-one and small group mentoring for young people aged 8 to 25. Programmes run for six to twelve weeks and are designed to address the specific challenges schools refer, including isolation, anxiety, school avoidance, grief, and criminal justice involvement.
Key features of Guardian Ballers’ individual mentoring offer include:
- Personalised programmes built around each young person’s needs and circumstances
- Delivery at the Guardian Ballers HQ near Coventry City Centre, or at the young person’s location on request
- A culturally aware approach, with 62% of participants from Black, Asian, and Minority Ethnic backgrounds
- AQA qualification pathways available through the provision
- A team that includes qualified educators, an experienced basketball coach, and a former paediatric speech and language therapist
- Free, funded, and commissioned options to remove financial barriers for schools and families
If you are a school professional looking for the right support for a student who is struggling, refer a young person or get in touch with the Guardian Ballers team to discuss what the right programme might look like.
Related Articles
- When should a school refer a teenager to alternative provision?
- What should schools look for in an alternative provision programme in 2026?
- How do you find the right alternative provision for a young person?
- What is early intervention for young people and why does it matter?
- How do schools refer a student to a one to one mentoring programme?