How does one to one mentoring help students with behavioural challenges?
One-to-one mentoring helps students with behavioural challenges by providing a consistent, trusted adult relationship in which a young person feels safe enough to explore the root causes of their behaviour. Rather than responding to behaviour as a problem to be managed, individual mentoring treats it as communication, a signal that something deeper needs attention. This article unpacks how that process works, who delivers it, and when schools should consider it.
What kinds of behavioural challenges does one-to-one mentoring address?
One-to-one mentoring for students is effective across a wide range of behavioural challenges, including persistent disruptiveness in class, school avoidance, aggression, social withdrawal, and low engagement with learning. These behaviours are rarely random: they typically reflect underlying difficulties such as anxiety, unresolved grief, trauma, family instability, or a sense of not belonging in school.
In practice, individual mentoring tends to be most impactful for young people presenting with:
- Frequent exclusions or risk of exclusion
- Chronically poor attendance or school refusal
- Emotional dysregulation and difficulty managing conflict
- Social isolation or difficulty forming peer relationships
- Involvement with the criminal justice system
- Grief, bereavement, or significant family disruption
- Anxiety that manifests as avoidance or confrontational behaviour
The common thread is that these young people have often disengaged from the systems designed to support them. A one-to-one relationship creates a different kind of entry point, one that does not begin with rules, targets, or assessments, but with genuine human connection.
How does one-to-one mentoring actually change student behaviour?
One-to-one mentoring changes student behaviour by building the psychological safety and self-awareness a young person needs to make different choices. When a student has a reliable, non-judgmental adult who listens consistently over time, they begin to develop trust, and trust is the foundation for any meaningful behavioural shift.
The mechanism is not simply about talking through problems. Effective mentoring works on several levels simultaneously. First, it helps young people identify the emotions and triggers that precede difficult behaviour. Second, it equips them with practical strategies for managing those moments. Third, it reinforces a positive sense of identity: the young person begins to see themselves as capable of change, not defined by past behaviour.
This process takes time. Behaviour that has developed over months or years will not shift after a single session. But consistent, structured mentoring, typically across six to twelve weeks, creates enough continuity for real patterns to emerge and for new responses to become habitual. The relationship itself is often what makes the difference: many students with behavioural challenges have experienced repeated disruptions in their relationships with adults, and experiencing a reliable, boundaried relationship is itself a formative experience.
What’s the difference between one-to-one mentoring and other behavioural interventions?
The key distinction is relational depth. Group interventions, behaviour management programmes, and in-class support strategies all have value, but they operate at scale; they cannot offer the sustained, personalised attention that one-to-one mentoring provides. Individual mentoring centres the young person’s specific story, not a generalised framework applied to many students at once.
Other common behavioural interventions tend to focus on managing or modifying behaviour in the moment, through reward systems, sanctions, or structured group work. These approaches can reduce incidents in the short term, but they do not always address why the behaviour is occurring. One-to-one mentoring goes upstream: it works with the young person to understand and shift the underlying conditions that are driving the behaviour.
Another important difference is flexibility. A skilled mentor can adjust their approach session by session, responding to what a young person brings on a given day. Group programmes follow a curriculum; mentoring follows the person. For students who have not responded to other interventions, this adaptability is often what finally breaks through.
Who delivers one-to-one mentoring for students with behavioural challenges?
One-to-one mentoring for students should be delivered by trained practitioners who combine professional knowledge with strong interpersonal skills and, ideally, lived experience relevant to the young people they are working with. Effective mentors are not simply supportive adults; they are skilled at building trust quickly, maintaining appropriate boundaries, and recognising when a young person needs to be referred to a higher level of clinical support.
In school settings, mentoring may be delivered by pastoral staff, learning mentors, or external specialists commissioned by the school. External provision tends to offer an important advantage: young people often engage more openly with someone who is not part of the school system, and who they do not associate with authority, judgement, or consequences.
The best providers bring multidisciplinary expertise to their teams. A strong mentoring offer for students with complex behavioural needs benefits from professionals who understand education, mental health, safeguarding, and youth development, not just one of those areas in isolation.
When should a school refer a student to one-to-one mentoring?
A school should consider referring a student to one-to-one mentoring when universal and targeted group support have not produced meaningful change, or when a student’s needs are too specific or complex to be met within a group setting. Early referral is always preferable to waiting until behaviour has escalated to a crisis point.
Specific indicators that a referral may be appropriate include:
- The student has experienced a significant life event such as bereavement, family breakdown, or trauma
- Behaviour has deteriorated despite existing pastoral support
- The student is disengaging from school and attendance is declining
- The student is reluctant or unable to engage in group settings
- There are concerns about the student’s mental health or emotional wellbeing
- The student is at risk of exclusion, or has already been excluded
Referral does not need to wait until every other option has been exhausted. For some students, one-to-one mentoring is the right first step, particularly where the young person is unlikely to engage with group-based provision or where the underlying issues are highly personal.
How long does one-to-one mentoring take to improve student behaviour?
Most structured one-to-one mentoring programmes run for six to twelve weeks, and meaningful behavioural improvement is typically observable within that timeframe when the young person is engaged and the relationship is working well. However, the pace of change varies significantly depending on the complexity of the student’s needs, their history with adults, and the consistency of the support around them.
It is important to set realistic expectations. Early sessions often focus on building the relationship rather than addressing behaviour directly, and this is not time wasted. A student who has learned to distrust adults may take several weeks before they begin to open up. Once that trust is established, progress can be rapid.
For students with longer-standing or more complex difficulties, ongoing or repeated mentoring blocks may be needed. A six-week programme might create a foundation that a further block consolidates. Schools should think of mentoring not as a single fix but as part of a broader, sustained commitment to a young person’s development.
How Guardian Ballers helps with behavioural challenges in students
Guardian Ballers is an Alternative Provision provider based near Coventry City Centre that works with young people aged 8 to 25 through structured one-to-one mentoring programmes. Sessions are delivered at the Guardian Ballers HQ or, where needed, at the young person’s own location, reducing barriers for students who struggle to access support. The organisation’s approach is built around three core pillars:
- BALL: using basketball as an engagement tool that builds confidence, physical wellbeing, and a sense of achievement
- BE: delivering mental and emotional wellbeing education that helps young people understand themselves and build resilience
- BETTER: connecting young people to community action and volunteering experiences that reinforce purpose and positive identity
Mentoring programmes run for six to twelve weeks and are tailored to individual needs, including challenges such as anxiety, school avoidance, grief, isolation, and criminal justice involvement. On average over three years, 85% of participants reported a positive impact on their wellbeing. Schools can refer students directly, and a range of funded and commissioned options are available to ensure access is not limited by cost. To find out more about Guardian Ballers’ impact or to explore a referral, get in touch with the team today.
Related Articles
- How does alternative provision support young people with anxiety?
- How do you find the right alternative provision for a young person?
- How do schools find the right alternative provision for school avoidance in 2026?
- When should a school consider one to one mentoring for a struggling student?
- What is the difference between early intervention and standard pastoral care?