When should a school refer a young person to alternative provision?
A school should refer a young person to alternative provision when their needs can no longer be met within a mainstream classroom setting and when continued placement without additional support risks further disengagement, harm to wellbeing, or stalled educational progress. This decision is rarely sudden: it typically follows a period of concern, internal support, and evidence that something different is needed. The questions below help school staff understand when and how to refer, and what to look for when considering a referral.
What counts as alternative provision in a school context?
Alternative provision (AP) refers to any education arranged for young people outside of a mainstream school setting, or delivered as a structured supplement to it. It is designed for pupils who are unable to access or benefit from standard classroom learning, whether due to exclusion, health needs, persistent absence, or social and emotional barriers. AP can be delivered on-site or off-site, by the school or by an external provider.
In practice, alternative provision for young people covers a wide range of formats. It might include specialist mentoring programmes, therapeutic interventions, vocational learning, sports-based education, or placements with community organisations. What unites them is the shared aim: to keep young people engaged with learning and personal development when the traditional school environment is not working for them.
AP is not only for pupils facing permanent exclusion. Many schools commission alternative provision as an early intervention, a way of addressing emerging difficulties before they escalate into crisis. Recognising this broader scope helps schools act earlier and with greater flexibility.
What are the signs a young person may need alternative provision?
The signs that a young person may need alternative provision include persistent school avoidance, a significant decline in attendance, repeated behavioural incidents, visible withdrawal or emotional distress, and a growing disconnect from peers and school life. These indicators often appear together and tend to worsen without targeted support.
School staff should pay particular attention to the following patterns:
- Persistent absence or a pattern of refusing to attend school
- Repeated fixed-term exclusions or escalating disciplinary referrals
- Signs of anxiety, low mood, or emotional dysregulation that affect daily functioning
- Social isolation or difficulty forming relationships with peers and staff
- Disengagement from lessons, low attainment despite apparent ability
- Involvement in or vulnerability to exploitation, risk-taking, or criminal activity
- Experiences of grief, trauma, or significant disruption at home
No single sign is sufficient on its own, but a cluster of these indicators, especially when internal pastoral support has not produced meaningful change, is a strong signal that a different kind of provision is needed. Early identification matters enormously: the longer a young person remains without the right support, the harder it becomes to re-engage them.
Who in a school is responsible for making an AP referral?
Responsibility for making an alternative provision referral typically sits with the school’s inclusion manager, SENCO, head of year, or deputy headteacher. In many schools, the safeguarding lead is also involved, particularly where a young person’s welfare is a concern. The referral is rarely made by one person alone; it is usually a collaborative decision informed by multiple members of staff.
In practice, the process often begins with a pastoral or inclusion team discussion. Evidence is gathered from form tutors, subject teachers, and support staff who have direct contact with the young person. Parents or carers are consulted, and where appropriate, the young person themselves is involved in the conversation.
Understanding who holds formal responsibility in your school is important, but so is creating a culture where any member of staff can raise a concern and have it taken seriously. The most effective referrals happen when schools have clear internal pathways that allow concerns to move quickly from classroom observation to decision-making.
How early should a school consider referring to alternative provision?
Schools should consider referring to alternative provision as soon as internal support has been tried and is not producing sufficient progress, and before a young person’s situation reaches crisis point. Waiting until a pupil is at risk of permanent exclusion or has stopped attending altogether is often too late for the smoothest possible intervention.
Early referral is consistently more effective than late referral. When alternative provision is introduced while a young person is still partially engaged with school, there is more to build on. Relationships are easier to form, attendance is easier to sustain, and the young person is more likely to see the provision as an opportunity rather than a last resort.
A useful benchmark: if a young person has been the subject of repeated pastoral concern over a half-term or more, and internal strategies have not led to meaningful improvement, that is the point to begin exploring AP options, not after the situation has further deteriorated.
What should schools look for in an alternative provision programme?
When evaluating alternative provision for young people, schools should look for programmes with a clear educational or developmental framework, experienced and qualified staff, a track record of measurable outcomes, and the flexibility to adapt to individual needs. Provision that combines structured activity with wellbeing support tends to produce stronger results than activity alone.
Use the following checklist when assessing a potential AP provider:
- Qualified and experienced staff: check the backgrounds of those delivering the programme, including any relevant teaching, therapeutic, or youth work qualifications
- A structured curriculum or framework: provision should have clear learning objectives, not just activities
- Accreditation or qualification opportunities: programmes that offer recognised qualifications such as AQA Unit Awards add tangible value for young people
- Safeguarding compliance: the provider must have up-to-date policies and DBS-checked staff
- Evidence of impact: ask for data on attendance, engagement, and outcomes from previous participants
- Flexibility and personalisation: the best AP providers tailor their approach to the individual rather than applying a one-size-fits-all model
- Communication with school: regular updates and shared reporting help schools maintain oversight and fulfil their duty of care
Programmes that address both the practical and emotional dimensions of a young person’s experience tend to be the most effective. Sport-based or activity-led provision, for example, can create the engagement and trust needed to then explore deeper wellbeing conversations.
What happens after a young person is referred to alternative provision?
After a referral is made, the AP provider will typically conduct an initial assessment or introductory meeting to understand the young person’s needs, background, and goals. A programme plan is then developed, often in collaboration with the school and family. Regular communication between the provider and school continues throughout the placement.
Most AP programmes involve a structured period of engagement, commonly six to twelve weeks for targeted interventions, though longer partnerships are also common. During this time, progress is monitored and shared with the school. Reviews are held to assess whether the provision is meeting the young person’s needs and to plan next steps.
The goal of alternative provision is not to permanently remove a young person from mainstream education, but to equip them with the resilience, skills, and confidence to re-engage, whether with school, further education, employment, or community life. A well-managed referral and placement process keeps that goal in view throughout.
How Guardian Ballers supports schools with alternative provision
Guardian Ballers is an alternative provision provider based near Coventry City Centre, working with young people aged 8 to 25 who are experiencing challenges including school avoidance, anxiety, isolation, grief, and involvement with the criminal justice system. Programmes are built around the BALL, BE, BETTER framework, combining basketball-based engagement with structured mental health education and real-world community action.
For schools, Guardian Ballers offers:
- One-to-one and small-group mentoring programmes running from 6 to 12 weeks
- Personalised referrals and targeted interventions tailored to individual need
- AQA Unit Award qualifications through the programme
- Whole-school wellbeing delivery, including PE, PSHE, and enrichment days
- Regular progress updates and collaborative working with school staff
- Programmes available at the Coventry HQ or delivered at the school’s location
Across a three-year average, 85% of participants reported that their Guardian Ballers experience positively impacted their wellbeing and physical activity levels. The organisation works specifically with young people from areas of socio-economic disadvantage and from BAME backgrounds, and ensures that girls and young women are well represented, making it a strong fit for schools seeking inclusive, evidence-informed provision. To find out more about how Guardian Ballers can support your students, explore the referral options or visit the impact page to see the outcomes in detail.
Related Articles
- How does alternative provision support young people with anxiety?
- How do you find the right alternative provision for a young person?
- What outcomes can schools expect from one to one mentoring for disengaged students?
- How does one to one mentoring help students with behavioural challenges?
- How do you measure progress in alternative provision for school avoidance?